saʴýҳ

HEALTHCARE

Presbyterian Healthcare Services to drop most Medicare Advantage plans, cut 150 jobs

CEO Rishi Sikka says the moves are ‘proactive’ decisions to increase access to care

Presbyterian Hospital near Downtown saʴýҳ. Presbyterian Healthcare Services said Tuesday it will cut most of its Medicare Advantage plans, as well as 150 employees.
Published Modified

Presbyterian Healthcare Services said Tuesday it will discontinue most of its Medicare Advantage plans beginning in 2027 and eliminate 150 administrative positions, the latest moves by a health system that has in recent years grappled with mounting financial losses and a failed merger attempt.

The saʴýҳ-based health system said the moves are proactive steps to preserve its financial footing and its status as an independent provider of healthcare across the state.

Rishi Sikka, Presbyterian CEO, said in an interview with the Journal that the health system plans to keep its Medicare Advantage Dual Plus Special Needs Plan, which serves about 13,000 people who receive both Medicare and Medicaid benefits. The cuts to its other plans, effective next year, will impact 30,000 members.

In moving to cut those plans, Presbyterian will void about $59 million in annual losses, which was “the loss profile last year” tied to Medicare Advantage, Sikka said.

A staff meeting was held earlier Tuesday, when the affected staff of the health system’s insurance arm, Presbyterian Health Plan, were informed of the layoffs. Sikka said cuts to those teams — spanning Medicare Advantage sales, IT configuration, project management and operational roles — were effective immediately.

Sikka said Presbyterian will offer severance and transition support, as well as the opportunity for terminated employees to apply for other open roles within the organization. The health system overall employs about 14,000 workers. 

“This decision is not impacting any clinical roles, nor is it impacting anything around the delivery of care,” Sikka said. In a separate statement from the company, Presbyterian noted it is actively trying to fill about 870 open clinical positions across its nine hospitals and scores of clinics.

Sikka added that Presbyterian is not yet able to “engage in a proactive outreach process” with affected Medicare Advantage members until fall open enrollment, which begins in October.

“That is going to be the opportunity where we will be able to proactively talk with all of our current members who receive their care with us and show them all the other alternatives that our organization contracts with, so that they can have continuity of care,” Sikka said. “There will be several alternatives for them in that regard.”

The announcement comes against a backdrop of recent financial strain for New Mexico’s largest health system.

Presbyterian posted back-to-back losses in fiscal years 2022 and 2023 — spending roughly $157 million more than it brought in during 2022, followed by a $159 million net loss the following year. Its most recent tax filings for the 2024 fiscal year showed the health system had a bit of a turnaround with a net income of $84 million, meaning it brought more money in than it spent.

The announcement also comes following a failed merger between Presbyterian and Iowa-based UnityPoint Health in October 2023, just over half a year after the two health systems made the announcement in what they said was a consolidation of administrative services.

Sikka on Tuesday downplayed any connection between that merger and its cutting of staff and Medicare Advantage plans, saying the recent moves are “very forward-facing” and “proactive” decisions to “ensure we have the ability to increase access to care.”

But the combination of the collapsed merger, its recent losses and the retreat from offering Medicare Advantage plans next year will likely give more ammunition to Presbyterian’s critics.

Sikka disagrees.

“I think it is (viable), and I think it’s also the best thing for the communities we serve, and for our state,” Sikka said, referring to keeping Presbyterian independent. “What we’ll start to communicate in the coming weeks and months ahead is the investments we will be making to expand access.”

Matthew Narvaiz is the Journal’s business editor. You can reach him at mnarvaiz@abqjournal.com